Psychologist Declares Death Row Inmate Incompetent Ahead of Court Decision

November 22, 2025 - 06:52

A psychologist issued his clinical opinion on Friday, stating that Ralph Menzies, a death row inmate, is incompetent to be executed. This assessment comes as Menzies had previously been scheduled for execution, but the decision was appealed, leading to a postponement. The psychologist's evaluation raises significant questions about Menzies' mental state and whether he possesses the necessary understanding of his situation and the consequences of his impending execution.

The Utah court is set to review this evaluation and make a determination in December regarding Menzies' competency. The implications of this ruling could have far-reaching effects on Menzies' case and the broader discourse surrounding the death penalty and mental health. Advocates for the mentally ill have long argued against executing individuals who are unable to comprehend their punishment, and this case may serve as a pivotal moment in that ongoing debate. The upcoming court decision will be closely watched as it unfolds.